Brewster Community Theater, in Carmel


There is a quality community theater group in Carmel.  Called Brewster Theater Company, it presents in a  spacious theater — nothing fancy, just nice — behind Drew United Methodist Church at 28 Gleneida Avenue in Carmel. (When, driving east from the lake, one comes to the end of Route 301, turn right; Drew is the first church — a big stone thing — on the left. There is parking at the back.)

The 2024 schedule includes Noises Off (April 19 – May 5) and Fiddler on the Roof.

One can pre-theater dine in walking distance to the theater at either the busy and happening Luigi’s Famiglia Cucina, Carmel Diner, Thai Golden, Bliss Dairy Bar and Grill, or the petite and lovely That Greek Place.

From the theater company website: “To audition for any show, please send an email to with the name of the show in the subject. Include your full contact information.”


Avg. Rating: 5

1 thought on “Brewster Community Theater, in Carmel”

  1. Guys & Dolls and That Greek Place was a delicious combination. Highly recommended.
    Looking forward to checking out Brewster Theater Company’s future productions.

    Rating: 5

Leave a Comment