Food, Culture and More in and Around Lake Sagamore

Supermarkets

1. ShopRite – 184 NY-52, Carmel
2. Stop&Shop – 1001 US-6, Mahopac
3. Tops – 1936 US-6, Carmel
4. DeCicco & Sons – 50 Independent Way, Brewster
5. Foodtown – 49 Chestnut Street, Cold Spring (Off Route 9D)
6. Uncle Giuseppe’s Marketplace – 327 Downing Dr. Yorktown Heights
7. Trader Joe’s – 3240 Crompond Road, Yorktown Heights

Specialty Grocery Stores

1. Ace Endico Marketplace– 80 International Blvd. Brewster, NY.
It is a wholesale food purveyor and distributor which sells to restaurants and other
food retailers. Its retail market offers a great selection of pasta, sauces, frozen food,
fresh vegetables and even kitchen tools and such.
2. Smoke Haus  Deli – 2449 Route 52, Hopewell Junction NY.
It sells homemade sausages, hot dogs, European condiments and more.
3. Rumcaj’s Polish Deli – 441 US-6, Mahopac, NY.
It sells polish sausages, eastern European dumplings, and condiments.
4. Polish Deli – 565 US-6, Mahopac, NY.
It sells similar goods as Rumcaj’s.
5. Adams Fairacre Farms – 160 Old Post Road, Wappingers Falls, NY.
It offers a wild variety of fresh organic vegetables, local products, and other standard
supermarket fare. It also sells plants, soil and pots.
6. H-Mart– 371 N. Central Avenue, Hartsdale, NY.\.
It sells Asian products, fresh seafood, meats and vegetables.
7. Boyd’s Corner Store – 2737 Route 301 (at Peekskill Hollow Road), Carmel, NY
It’s close to the Lake and a convenient spot to pick up milk, pizza or sandwiches.
8. Glynwood Farm Store – 362 Glynwood Road, Cold Spring
It sells organic farm goods in an idyllic setting. Limited hours.
9. Vera’s Marketplace – 3091 Route 9
It sells upscale groceries and seasonal fruit and vegetables.
10. Marbled Meat Shop – 3091 Route 9
It sells high-end and pasture-raised meats including, beef, pork, lamb and chicken.
11. Cold Spring Seafood – 3182 Route 9
It sells high quality seafood, raw and prepared.
12. Fishkill Farm – 9 Fishkill Farm Road, Hopewell Junction
It operates a farm store throughout the year. Seasonally, it operates a cider bar with
lunch menu, pick-your own and x-country skiing.

Local Restaurants

1. That Greek Place – 3 Fair Street, Carmel, NY.
It offers traditional Greek cuisine. On Friday and Saturday, it usually offers fish
specials.
2. El Mariachi – 4081 NY-52, Holmes, NY.
It offers standard Mexican fare.
3. Pho 6 – 734 US-6, Mahopac.
It offers Chinese and Vietnamese dishes.
4. Choi’s BBQ – 732 US-6, Mahopac, NY.
It offers Korean grilled BBG and other standard fare.
5. Cathryn’s – 91 Main Street, Cold Spring, NY
It offers American and Mediterranean dishes.
6. Riverview restaurant – 45 Fair Street, Cold Spring, NY (Note: cash only)
It offers American cuisine.
7. Hudson House – 2 Main Street, Cold Spring, NY (situated along the Hudson
River)
It offers American cuisine.
8. Juanita’s Kitchen – 289 Main Street, Cold Spring
It sells standard Mexican fare in a cozy and cheery setting.
9. Rincon Argentina – 21 Main Street, Cold Spring
It sells empanadas, sweets and more.
10. Thai Golden – 5 Seminary Hill Road, Carmel
It offers Thai food with indoor and outdoor seating.

Art, Music, and Cultural Offerings

1. Arts on the Lake – 640 NY-52, Carmel, NY
It provides a variety of arts and musical programs for children and adults.
2. Tompkins Corners Cultural Center – 729 Peekskill Hollow Rd, Putnam Valley NY.
It hosts a wide range of events such as concerts, play readings, art shows and
festivals.
3. The Brewster Theater Company – Drew United Methodist Church 28 Gleneida
Avenue, Carmel, NY (planning to move to 69 Gleneida Avenue, Carmel)
It offers performances of plays and musicals throughout the year.
4. Caramoor Center for Music and the Arts – 149 Girdle Ridge Road, Katonah, NY.
It offers live music performances featuring genres from classical to jazz throughout
the year.
5. The Schoolhouse Theater Company – 3 Owens Road, North Salem, NY.
It offers performances of plays, comedy, jazz and storytelling.
6. Magazzino Italian Art Museum – 2700 Route 9, Cold Spring
A boutique museum which features postwar and contemporary Italian art.
7. Stonecrop Gardens – Route 301, Cold Spring
A 15-acre public garden with a diverse collection of plants and gardens.

8. Manitoga – Route 9W, Garrison
Beautiful home and grounds of the mid-century designer, Russel Wright
9. Dia Beacon – Beacon
Features an outstanding collection of contemporary art.
10. Hudson Valley Shakespeare Company – Route 9, Garrison
It offers performances of Shakespearean and other plays in the summer.
11. Bannerman Castle – a quirky historic castle on an island in Hudson River.
It offers tours which leave from Beacon.
12. Chuan Yen Monastery – Route 301, Carmel
A Buddhist monastery on 225 serene acres featuring the largest Buddha statue in
North America, a world-class library of Buddhist literature , a lake and pavilions.
13. The Falcon – 1348 US-9W, Marlboro
A live music venue/restaurant/bar perched over a waterfall. It features local and
international jazz and pop artists.
14. Walkway Over the Hudson State Historic Park– 61 Parker Avenue, Poughkeepsie
Liquor Stores and Brewery
1. Sloop Brewing Company – 755 East Drive, Hopewell Junction
2. Viscount Wines and Liquor – 1173 US-9, Wappingers Fall
3. Depot Wines and Liquors – 100 Independent Way, Brewster

Compiled by the Welcoming Committee in January 2026 from lake neighbors’
input. This list will be updated from time to time.